Home / News / 4 Reasons for a Surprising Change in Racial Incarceration Trendlines

4 Reasons for a Surprising Change in Racial Incarceration Trendlines

Photo Credit: Image by Shutterstock, Copyright (c) Willee Cole

It’s prolonged been a given that secular disparities disease the nation’s rapist probity system. That’s still true—black people are jailed at a rate 5 times aloft than that of white people—but the disparities are decreasing, and there are a series of engaging reasons behind the trend. 

That’s according to a report expelled this month by the Marshall Project, a non-profit news classification that covers the U.S. rapist probity system. Researchers reviewed annual reports from the sovereign Bureau of Justice Statistics and the FBI’s Uniform Crime Reporting complement and found that between 2000 and 2015, the bonds rate for black men forsaken by scarcely a entertain (24 percent). During the same period, the white male bonds rate bumped up slightly, the BJS numbers indicate.

When it comes to women, the numbers are even some-more striking. While the black womanlike bonds rate plummeted by scarcely 50 percent in the first 15 years of this century, the white rate jumped by a whopping 53 percent.


Make no mistake: Racial disparities in bonds haven’t left away. As the NAACP notes, African Americans comment for only 12 percent of the U.S. population, but 34 percent of the race in jail or jail or on release or probation. Similarly, black children comment for 32 percent of all children who are arrested and some-more than 50 percent of children who are charged as adults.

When it comes to drugs, the NAACP reports, African Americans use drugs in suit to their share of the race (12.5 percent), but comment for 29 percent of all drug arrests and 33 percent of state drug prisoners. Black people still bear the heaviest weight of drug law enforcement.

Still, that 5:1 ratio for black vs. white male bonds rates in 2015 was an 8:1 ratio 15 years earlier. Likewise, that 2:1 allotment for black vs. white womanlike bonds rates was a 6:1 ratio in 2000.

“It’s really confident news,” Fordham University law highbrow and seizure trends consultant John Pfaff told the Marshall Project. “But the secular inconsistency stays so immeasurable that it’s flattering tough to celebrate. How, exactly, do you speak about ‘less horrific?’”

It behooves analysts and policy-makers comparison to try to make clarity of the changing mettle of the jail population, but that’s no easy task.

“Our inability to explain it suggests how feeble we know the mechanics behind bonds in general,” Pfaff said.

Still, the Marshall Project wanted some answers, so it did some-more investigate and interviewed some-more jail complement experts. Here are 4 theories, not jointly exclusive, that try to yield them.

1. Shifting Drug War Demographics

The black vs. white inconsistency in the charge of the fight on drugs is notorious, and a executive principle of drug remodel advocacy. But even yet black Americans continue to humour drug arrests, prosecutions, and seizure at a distant larger rate than whites, something has been happening: According to BJS statistics, the black bonds rate for drug offenses fell by 16 percent between 2000 and 2009; at the same time, the series of whites going to jail for drugs jumped by scarcely 27 percent.

This could be given the drug crises of the day, methamphetamines and heroin and medication opioid addiction, are problems generally for white people. Back in the 1980s and 1990s, the drug crisis du jour was moment cocaine, and even yet moment enjoyed recognition among all races, the fight on moment was waged almost wholly in black communities. The fight on moment gathering black bonds rates aloft then, but now cops have other priorities.

The change in drug fight targeting could also explain the thespian squeezing of the secular opening among women prisoners, given women prisoners are disproportionately detained for drug crimes.

2. White People Blues

Declining socioeconomic prospects for white people may also be personification a role. Beginning around 2000, whites started going to jail some-more mostly for skill offenses, with the rate jumping 21 percent by 2009. Meanwhile, the black bonds rate for skill crimes forsaken 9 percent.

Analysts advise that an altogether decrease in life prospects for white people in new decades may have led to an boost in steal among that population, generally for crimes of poverty, such as skill crimes. A much-discussed study by economists Anne Case and Angus Deaton found that between 1998 and 2013, white Americans were experiencing spikes in rates of mortality, suicide, and ethanol and drug abuse. That’s precisely when these secular shifts in seizure were happening.

And while African Americans also faced tough times, many whites were newer to the knowledge of poverty, which, in an reason the Marshall Project says is “speculative,” could explain because drug use rates, skill crime, and bonds rates are all up:

“Perhaps, says Marc Mauer, executive executive of the Sentencing Project, whites are just newer to the knowledge of poverty, which could explain because their rates of drug use, skill crime and bonds have ticked up so suddenly.”

3. Reform Is More Likely in the Cities, Where More Black People Live

Since the commencement of this century, rapist probity remodel has begun to put the put brakes on the mass bonds engine, but reforms haven’t been uniform. They are much some-more likely to have occurred in some-more magnanimous states and big cities than in conservative, farming areas. And while people are still being arrested for drugs at sky-high rates—more than 1.5 million drug arrests in 2016, according to the FBI—those reforms meant that fewer of them are finale up in prison. 

In big cities such as Los Angeles and Brooklyn, new jail admissions have plummeted interjection mostly to sentencing and other rapist probity reforms. But in counties with fewer than 100,000 residents, the bonds rate was going up even as crime went down. In fact, people from farming areas are 50 percent some-more likely to be sent to jail than city dwellers.

Even in magnanimous states, the impact of reforms varies geographically. After New York state repealed its draconian Rockefeller drug laws, the state reduced its jail race some-more than any other state in the country in the 2000s. But the decrease came almost wholly from the distant some-more different New York City, not the whiter, some-more farming areas of the state.

4. Crime Has Been Declining Overall

Arrests for scarcely all forms of crime rose into the mid-1990s, then declined dramatically, inspiring African Americans some-more significantly than whites given they were (and are) some-more likely to be arrested by police in the first place. In the first decade of the new century, arrests of black people for aroused offenses forsaken 22 percent; for whites, the decrease was 11 percent. Since those offenses are likely to outcome in estimable jail sentences, this change has likely contributed to the changing secular makeup of the jail population.

Whatever the reason for the timorous secular disparities in the jail population, there is a prolonged way to go between here and a racially just rapist probity system. If stream trends continue, it would still take decades for the disparities to disappear. 

Phillip Smith is editor of the AlterNet Drug Reporter and author of the Drug War Chronicle.

auto magazine

Check Also

Because ‘Nothing Has Changed Since Columbine,’ Students, Teachers Call for Nationwide School Walkouts

Photo Credit: By Nicole S Glass / Shutterstock.com As families continue to suffer and hold funerals for …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>